Life Insurance Interpleader After a New Jersey Divorce

David Cardamone, Esq. | Admitted in New Jersey (2010)

Reach the firm about this

In most New Jersey divorce settlement agreements where support is being paid, the support is secured by life insurance. This means that the payor of support is required to maintain a certain amount of insurance for a specific period of time for the benefit of either their ex-spouse or their children.

Ideally, on an annual basis, proof of life insurance coverage is provided. However, obtaining this proof is often one of the most overlooked aspects of “enforcing” the terms of a divorce judgment for a myriad of reasons.

What Happens When the Beneficiary Was Changed After the Divorce

The situation often arises whereby upon the entry of the divorce proof of the required insurance is provided then life happens and a few years later the payor dies. Suddenly, the required beneficiary discovers that the life insurance beneficiary designation had been changed since the entry of the divorce. This can happen for various reasons, often due to remarriage or simply identifying a different beneficiary when the coverage is changed (especially with employer provided plans upon change of employment). But the reason does not matter, ultimately.

The alimony and/or child support (and even intended contribution to college expenses for children) was anticipated to continue and was relied upon to pay your household expenses. With the support stream ending, receiving that lump sum of money was imperative to maintaining your bills.

So if it is not available to you, what are your options?

Option 1: Enforce the Divorce Agreement Against the Estate

There are two (2) options in pursuing your remedies. The first is to seek to enforce the settlement agreement in your divorce against the Estate of your ex-spouse. In this scenario, you would be pursuing damages from the Estate’s assets, which may or may not include life insurance policies paid into the Estate. The potential downside of this option is that you may be taking funds that were earmarked for your children to cover an obligation owed to yourself and/or your children. However, if there was no life insurance in place at the time of death, this would be your only option.

Option 2: Seek a Constructive Trust Over the Policy Proceeds

The second option, assuming there is a life insurance policy in place but with a different beneficiary, is to pursue a claim against the policy essentially asking that a constructive trust be applied to the policy proceeds for your benefit.

What Is an Interpleader Action?

An Interpleader action is a lawsuit in which a party holding money that two or more people claim, here the life insurance company, deposits the money with the Court and asks the Court to decide who is entitled to it. To start, you would formally assert a claim directly to the life insurance company. Presumably, the named beneficiary would also assert a claim, but even if they didn’t, once the life insurance company recognizes that there is a dispute as to the beneficiary, they will initiate an Interpleader action, often in Federal Court, to deposit the funds into the Court asserting that they have no interest in who receives the funds and leaving it to the Court to make that determination, freeing themselves of any further obligations.

Employer-Provided Policies and ERISA

If the policy was provided through your ex-spouse’s employer, it is likely governed by a federal law known as ERISA. That matters for two reasons. First, the plan administrator is generally required to pay the person named on the plan’s beneficiary form, regardless of what your divorce agreement says. Second, the New Jersey law that revokes a former spouse’s beneficiary designation upon divorce does not apply to ERISA plans. This does not mean you are without a remedy. Once the plan has paid, a claim may be brought against the person who received the proceeds. But the claim is against the recipient rather than the plan, and the process is different.

How Quickly Do You Need to Act?

Quickly. A life insurance company will generally pay the named beneficiary once it receives a death certificate and a claim form, and that can happen within weeks. Once the money is paid out, recovering it becomes more difficult, particularly if it has been spent. As soon as you learn of the death, you should put the insurance company on written notice of your claim and provide a copy of your divorce judgment and settlement agreement. Notice of a competing claim is what causes the insurance company to hold the funds and file an Interpleader action. If your claim is against the Estate, there are separate deadlines for presenting claims, so you should not wait.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an interpleader a lawsuit?

Yes. An interpleader is a lawsuit, but it is filed by the life insurance company rather than by either person claiming the money. The insurance company names each claimant as a defendant, deposits the proceeds with the Court, and asks to be dismissed from the case. The claimants then litigate against each other over who is entitled to the funds.

How long does a life insurance interpleader take?

It depends on how contested the claims are. A case that settles early can be resolved in a few months. A case that proceeds through discovery, motions or trial commonly takes a year or longer. The proceeds remain on deposit with the Court until the case is resolved by settlement or court order.

How do I respond to an interpleader complaint?

You must file a written answer with the Court by the deadline stated in the summons. Your answer should assert your claim to the proceeds and the basis for it, including the terms of your divorce judgment or settlement agreement. If you do not respond in time, the Court can enter default against you and award the proceeds to the other claimant. If you have been served with an interpleader complaint, you should contact an attorney immediately.

Does divorce automatically revoke a life insurance beneficiary in New Jersey?

Generally, yes. Under N.J.S.A. 3B:3-14, a divorce revokes a former spouse’s designation as the beneficiary of a life insurance policy unless the policy, a court order or the divorce agreement provides otherwise. That exception is important. If your divorce judgment or settlement agreement requires your ex-spouse to maintain life insurance for you or your children, that obligation controls. The statute also does not apply to employer-provided policies governed by ERISA.

Can my ex change the life insurance beneficiary during or after a New Jersey divorce?

While the divorce is pending, each party must file a certification listing all insurance coverage, including the beneficiaries of any life insurance, and under the court rules that coverage must be maintained until the Court orders otherwise. After the divorce, your ex-spouse may change the beneficiary on any coverage beyond what the judgment or settlement agreement requires. The insurance company, however, does not enforce your divorce agreement. It will process a change of beneficiary form when one is submitted, which is why the change is often not discovered until after death.

Are life insurance proceeds taxable in New Jersey?

Generally, no. Life insurance proceeds paid to a named beneficiary are exempt from New Jersey inheritance tax, and the death benefit is generally not treated as income for federal income tax purposes. Proceeds paid to the Estate are treated differently, and interest earned on the proceeds, including interest that accrues while the funds are on deposit with the Court, may be taxable. You should confirm the tax treatment of any recovery with an accountant.

Talk to a New Jersey Family Law Attorney

Often, the amount of life insurance at issue is substantial, and the different mechanisms for ensuring you receive your funds can be complicated, which is why it is important to retain an attorney to assist you in navigating the process which may play out in both state court and federal court simultaneously.

Last updated November 19, 2026

Disclaimer

This article provides general information about the law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change, and this article reflects the law as of the date shown. Buchan & Cardamone is a New Jersey law firm. For advice about your situation, consult an attorney.

Questions about family law?

This form goes directly to the firm's family law practice.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not include confidential details.